Skip to content
Animal of Things
Features · 9 mins read

Indiana Drivers Face About 1 in 116 Odds of an Animal Collision Claim, and November Is the Month When Deer Crashes Peak

Cody Barrett

Cody Barrett

November 19, 2026

Your Odds of Hitting a Deer in Indiana This Season
Spread the love for animals! 🐾

Your odds of hitting a deer in Indiana this season are not a single fixed number, and they swing hard with the calendar. Nationally, State Farm’s annual analysis puts the average U.S. driver at a 1 in 145 chance of an animal collision. Indiana sits above that risk level, and the weeks from October through December carry most of it.

This article walks through the Indiana numbers: where the state ranks, which months and hours are worst, what a crash costs, and how insurance and reporting work. It also covers the roads and habits that change your own odds, so you can plan your fall driving with real data instead of guesswork.

Your Odds of Hitting a Deer in Indiana This Season (Short Answer)

As of State Farm’s 2025-2026 analysis, an Indiana driver has about a 1 in 116 chance of an animal collision claim, according to a state-by-state compilation of the insurer’s data. That is a little worse than the national figure of 1 in 145. The odds are not spread evenly across the year, though.

October, November, and December are the danger months. Weather.com reports that those three months alone make up 41% of all animal collision claims nationally, and November is the single worst month. If you drive rural Indiana roads at dusk in mid-November, your personal odds are well above the annual average.

Key Insight: An annual “1 in 116” figure hides the seasonal spike. Your risk in mid-November is much higher than in March, and your risk at 6 p.m. is much higher than at noon.

How Indiana Ranks for Deer and Animal Collisions

State Farm ranks every state by the chance its drivers file an animal collision claim. Indiana lands in the middle of the pack, at rank 23 in the 2025-2026 analysis as compiled by mywild.report. For comparison, State Farm’s top of the list runs West Virginia (1 in 46), Montana (1 in 54), Wisconsin (1 in 62), Pennsylvania (1 in 64), Michigan (1 in 68), and Iowa (1 in 81).

Indiana’s neighbors help put the ranking in context. Michigan is far riskier, while the odds in Indiana are closer to the national middle. If you also drive in Ohio or Illinois, see our guides to deer season in Ohio and deer season in Illinois for how each state’s herd management plays out.

How the Odds in Indiana Compare With the National Average

State Farm reports the national odds improved to 1 in 145 for the 12 months ended June 30, 2026, up from 1 in 139 a year earlier, according to CollisionWeek. The insurer estimated more than 1.6 million animal collision claims industry-wide in that period, down from 1.7 million the year before.

AreaOdds of an Animal Collision ClaimSource Period
United States average1 in 145July 2025 to June 2026
Indiana1 in 1162025-2026 analysis
West Virginia (highest)1 in 46July 2025 to June 2026

Older State Farm snapshots put Indiana at 1 in 100 in one year and 1 in 142 in another, so the number moves from year to year. Treat any single figure as a range rather than a promise.

When Are Deer Collisions Most Likely in Indiana? (Month by Month)

The Indiana DNR says collisions are most likely from September through December, particularly October and November. The DNR’s own data for Monroe County, as reported by the B Square Bulletin, uses an average annual peak day calculated from crash records going back to 2003.

Joe Caudell of the Indiana DNR told an Evansville newspaper that collisions begin rising in September and peak in mid-November. State Farm’s national ranking agrees: November first, then October, then December.

  • January through August: Lower, steadier risk, with a smaller bump in late spring when young deer disperse.
  • September: Crashes start climbing as crops come down and deer shift feeding patterns.
  • October and November: The rut drives the sharpest spike.
  • December: Still elevated, then falling through January.

Deer Rut and Hunting Season in Indiana: Why Fall Is Riskiest

Purdue Extension explains, citing the Indiana DNR, that the white-tailed deer breeding season primarily occurs in October and November. Bucks roam widely looking for does and pay less attention to traffic. Hunters add pressure that keeps deer moving, and harvest-season farm work removes cover and pushes deer toward roadside edges.

Indiana’s season dates shape that movement. One season roundup lists archery from Oct. 1 to Jan. 7 and firearms in mid-November through early December. Our Indiana deer hunting season guide has the full 2026-27 dates, and the Indiana DNR deer-vehicle collision page carries the official safety guidance.

Pro Tip: Firearms season weekends in mid-November overlap with the peak collision window. Expect more deer movement on rural roads near public hunting land.

Time of Day and Daylight Saving Time: When Deer Crashes Happen in Indiana

The DNR notes that deer are most active when many people are commuting, which is why crashes cluster at dawn and dusk. Consumer Reports adds that deer are most active at dawn and between 6 p.m. and 9 p.m., so high beams help at those times.

Daylight saving time ending moves the evening commute into darkness right as the rut peaks. Weather.com cites one study finding collisions are 14 times more frequent in the two hours after sunset than before sunset. That shift is why early November feels like a sudden jump in near misses.

Purdue Extension’s Whitley County educator said most collisions occur from dusk to dawn on high-speed rural roads.

How Many Deer Crashes Happen in Indiana Each Year?

The Indiana DNR says more than 15,000 deer-vehicle collisions are reported annually to the Indiana Department of Transportation. Earlier DNR messaging used a figure of more than 14,000, and Indiana State Police statistics counted 16,448 deer collisions in 2023.

These counts only include reported crashes. Many minor strikes never reach police records, which is one reason insurer-based odds and police-based counts do not match.

Which Roads and Counties in Indiana See the Most Deer Crashes?

In 2022, 64% of deer-related accidents in Indiana happened on state or county roads, according to a WSBT report citing the DNR. High-speed rural roads with field and forest edges are the classic setup.

Cities are not exempt. The DNR’s deer information map places most of Bloomington in its densest category of more than 40 deer per square mile, and Monroe County recorded 169 collisions in 2024 and 185 in 2025. A Purdue and Indiana DNR study of 300,000 collisions from 2003 to 2022 also found that one part of northeastern Indiana had a rate nearly twice as high as other areas.

For county-level numbers, the DNR publishes a deer information map and an annual white-tailed deer report that list collisions by county.

Other Animals You Could Hit in Indiana

Deer lead the list, but they are not alone. A State Farm summary reported by a regional radio station said deer were the top animal struck in Indiana, followed by rodents, dogs, raccoons, and coyotes. DNR figures reviewed by the B Square Bulletin show deer account for roughly three-quarters of crashes classified as involving an animal or object in the roadway.

That means a quarter of animal-related crashes involve something else. Raccoons and opossums are common at night in towns, while dogs and coyotes show up on rural stretches.

How Much Does a Deer Collision Cost in Indiana?

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety figure cited by Purdue puts the national average deer claim at $3,995, with about 150 deaths and over $1 billion in vehicle damage a year. WSBT reported that one insurer said damages can run up to $10,000 depending on the crash.

The wider economic bill is much bigger. A Purdue and Indiana DNR study estimated deer-vehicle collisions cost Indiana society more than $2.5 billion over two decades, as covered by the NRA Hunters’ Leadership Forum.

State Farm alone paid $1.9 billion in animal collision claims nationally in the 12 months ended June 30, 2026.

Does Car Insurance Cover Hitting a Deer in Indiana?

Usually, yes, if you carry comprehensive coverage. State Farm notes that coverage depends on your policy terms, your state, and the circumstances of the crash. Liability-only policies do not pay for damage to your own car.

Swerving and hitting a tree or another car is treated differently from striking the deer, which is another reason the DNR says never to swerve. Check your deductible before the season starts, since a $1,000 deductible can swallow a minor repair.

Do You Have to Report a Deer Collision in Indiana?

Indiana State Police advise that after a deer strike you move off the roadway, stay away from the animal, and file a crash report. The DNR says to pull to a safe spot, turn on hazards, and call the police.

Reporting also helps with insurance, since a police report documents the cause. If the deer dies, a conservation officer, DNR property manager, or other law enforcement officer can issue a permit to keep it, and the DNR notes that selling wild deer meat is illegal in Indiana. Donation through the Hunt for Hunger program is another option.

How to Lower Your Odds of Hitting a Deer in Indiana

You cannot remove the risk, but you can shrink it. The Indiana DNR’s top advice is to never swerve, because braking and hitting the deer is safer than leaving the road.

  1. Slow down at dawn, dusk, and after dark in October through December.
  2. Assume more deer are following when you see one.
  3. Use high beams at night when no traffic is ahead, to catch eye shine.
  4. Keep your phone down. State Farm says risky behavior such as speeding or phone use raises animal strike likelihood by 23%.
  5. Skip deer whistles. State Farm says no scientific evidence supports that car-mounted whistles work.

Common Mistake: Swerving hard to miss a deer. Wounded or fleeing deer are unpredictable, and leaving the road often causes the worst injuries.

Related reading on seasonal wildlife timing includes our Ohio season dates and Pennsylvania season dates, both high-collision neighbors.

Your Odds of Hitting a Deer in Indiana: Frequently Asked Questions

What are the odds of hitting a deer in Indiana?

Roughly 1 in 116 for an animal collision claim in State Farm’s 2025-2026 analysis as compiled by mywild.report, compared with 1 in 145 nationally.

What month are deer crashes most common in Indiana?

November is the peak, with October and December close behind, according to State Farm and the Indiana DNR.

What time of day should I be most careful?

Dawn and the evening hours, especially between 6 p.m. and 9 p.m., when deer are active and commuters are on the road.

Should I swerve to avoid a deer?

No. The Indiana DNR says braking and hitting the deer is safer than swerving off the road.

Can I keep a deer I hit?

Possibly. A law enforcement officer or DNR property manager can issue a possession permit, and the DNR says selling wild deer meat is illegal.

Spread the love for animals! 🐾

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *