New Jersey Ranks Low for Deer Collision Odds at 1 in 245, but Record Crashes Make November the Month to Fear
November 22, 2026
Your odds of hitting a deer in New Jersey this season look low on paper, since State Farm’s 2025-2026 analysis puts the chance of an animal collision at 1 in 245 and ranks the state 39th out of 51. Yet the Garden State logged a record 11,692 deer crashes in 2025, and most of them cluster in the weeks you are driving through right now.
That gap between a “low likelihood” ranking and record crash counts is the whole story. New Jersey is small, crowded and heavily driven, so even a modest per-driver chance adds up to a deer crash roughly every 45 minutes.
This article breaks down the odds, the calendar, the roads and counties with the most crashes, what a collision costs, and how insurance and reporting rules work. Where a figure comes from a specific agency, the source and period are named so you can judge how current it is.
Your Odds of Hitting a Deer in New Jersey This Season (Short Answer)
The short answer: about 1 in 245 per year for an animal collision claim, according to State Farm’s 2025-2026 analysis. That puts New Jersey in the low-likelihood group nationally, but the annual figure hides a sharp seasonal spike.
Crash data from AAA Northeast shows more than 43% of deer crashes from 2020 through 2025 happened between September and November. November alone accounted for 20%, and drivers were nearly three times more likely to be in a deer crash that month than in any other.
So if you commute at dawn or dusk in November, your personal risk is far higher than the yearly average suggests.
How New Jersey Ranks for Deer and Animal Collisions
New Jersey sits 39th of 51 in State Farm’s ranking of the 50 states and the District of Columbia, which puts it in the low-likelihood category. States with big rural road networks and large deer herds fill the top of that list, while dense Northeast states tend to land lower.
Other published estimates vary because they use different insurer datasets. Patch reported an industrywide casualty claims figure of 1 in 213 for New Jersey, and another outlet cited State Farm data showing 1 in 226 in an earlier year. Treat these as the same ballpark, roughly 1 in 210 to 1 in 250, depending on the dataset and year.
| Measure | New Jersey Figure | Period |
|---|---|---|
| State Farm odds of an animal collision | 1 in 245 | 2025-2026 analysis |
| State Farm national rank | 39th of 51 | 2025-2026 analysis |
| Record deer crashes | 11,692 | Calendar year 2025 |
How the Odds in New Jersey Compare With the National Average
State Farm’s annual analysis gives U.S. drivers an average 1 in 145 chance of colliding with an animal. New Jersey’s 1 in 245 means a typical Garden State driver is meaningfully less likely to file an animal collision claim than the average American.
Put another way, the national average is roughly 70% more likely than New Jersey’s figure. That is a drop in per-driver risk, not an absence of risk.
The reason raw crash counts still climb is volume. New Jersey packs millions of vehicles onto a small land area where suburban sprawl meets woodland, so the sheer number of drivers exposed to deer edge habitat keeps totals high.
Key Insight: A low per-driver ranking and a record crash count are not contradictory. Ranking measures your chance as an individual; the record measures how many drivers share the same roads.
When Are Deer Collisions Most Likely in New Jersey? (Month by Month)
November is the clear peak. AAA Northeast’s analysis of state crash data found that month produced 20% of all New Jersey deer crashes between 2020 and 2025, and the three-month stretch from September through November produced more than 43%.
Another local analysis points to October through December as the broader peak window. Here is how the year breaks down in practical terms:
- January to August: Lower, steadier risk. Deer still cross roads anywhere and at any time of year, but they are less erratic.
- September to October: Risk climbs as bucks begin moving more and fall activity builds.
- November: Highest-risk month by a wide margin.
- December: Still elevated as the mating season winds down, with early sunsets keeping commutes in low light.
Plan your riskiest driving, such as rural back roads at dusk, with that calendar in mind.
Deer Rut and Hunting Season in New Jersey: Why Fall Is Riskiest
The fall rut drives the spike. The New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection urges extra caution during deer mating season because increased white-tailed deer activity near roadways lines up with morning and evening commutes, when darkness or sun glare limits visibility.
NJDEP Assistant Commissioner Dave Golden has said that most of the thousands of deer-vehicle collisions in the state each year happen during the fall mating season. During the rut, bucks pursue does and are far less cautious about traffic.
Hunting seasons overlap with the rut and can push deer to move, though the mating drive is the main factor. If you want the dates for when hunters are afield, see our breakdown of the New Jersey deer hunting season.
Deer also travel in groups, so one animal crossing often means another is close behind.
Time of Day and Daylight Saving Time: When Deer Crashes Happen in New Jersey
Deer are most active around sunrise and sunset, which is exactly when commuters are on the road. According to reporting that cites the state, about 77% of New Jersey deer crashes happen during the evening rush.
Daylight saving time makes this worse. Once the clocks fall back in early November, sunset moves into the evening commute, and the NJDEP has noted that earlier twilight raises collision risk because deer movement and rush-hour traffic overlap.
Pro Tip: The first week after clocks change is when many drivers get caught off guard. Treat your usual 5 p.m. drive home as a dusk drive and slow down on wooded stretches.
How Many Deer Crashes Happen in New Jersey Each Year?
AAA Northeast, using state crash data from Numetric, reports a record 11,692 deer crashes in New Jersey in 2025, nearly 2% above the previous record set in 2024. That works out to a crash about every 45 minutes, or around 32 a day.
From 2020 through 2025, deer crashes totaled 64,780, with more than 4,252 resulting in an injury and 15 in a fatality. Separate NJDOT data reported by 94.3 The Point counted 33,700 animal crashes statewide from 2023 through 2025, more than 11,000 a year, with deer behind the vast majority.
| Period | Deer Crashes | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 11,692 (record) | AAA Northeast / Numetric |
| 2020 to 2025 combined | 64,780 | AAA Northeast / Numetric |
| 2023 to 2025 (all animals) | 33,700 | NJDOT via 94.3 The Point |
AAA attributes the long-term rise to growing deer populations and development that encroaches on habitat.
Which Roads and Counties in New Jersey See the Most Deer Crashes?
Monmouth County leads the state. AAA Northeast’s 2025 county ranking shows Monmouth at 1,300 crashes, followed by Burlington at 959 and Morris at 937. The pattern is suburban and exurban rather than rural-only.
| Rank | County | Deer Crashes (2025) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Monmouth | 1,300 |
| 2 | Burlington | 959 |
| 3 | Morris | 937 |
| 4 | Somerset | 840 |
| 5 | Bergen | 828 |
| 6 | Hunterdon | 817 |
| 7 | Ocean | 791 |
| 8 | Middlesex | 737 |
| 9 | Sussex | 628 |
| 10 | Camden | 502 |
At the town level, AAA’s top municipalities were Raritan Township in Hunterdon County (165), Middletown Township in Monmouth (161) and Bridgewater Township in Somerset (148). Manchester, Jackson, Wall, Franklin, Mount Laurel, Howell and Hillsborough townships round out the top ten.
Monmouth had 3,831 animal crashes from 2023 through 2025 in NJDOT data, nearly 1,200 more than second-place Burlington, and eight of one outlet’s top 25 towns sit in Monmouth or Ocean counties.
Other Animals You Could Hit in New Jersey
Deer dominate, but they are not alone. NJDOT data shows more than 11,000 animal crashes a year statewide, and deer account for the vast majority, which leaves a smaller share for everything else.
That remainder includes raccoons, foxes, opossums, coyotes and, in northern counties, black bears. New Jersey’s black bear population is concentrated in the northwest, so Sussex, Passaic, Morris and Warren county drivers face a different kind of large-animal risk, especially in spring and fall.
Smaller animals rarely cause serious injury, but swerving for them can. The same rule applies to every animal: brake firmly and stay in your lane.
How Much Does a Deer Collision Cost in New Jersey?
Repair bills vary widely with the vehicle and how directly you hit the deer. NJ101.5 reported a statewide cost figure for 2025 tied to the AAA crash totals, so check that report for AAA’s per-crash estimate.
The injury side is better documented. AAA found injuries in 4.5% of crashes where drivers struck a deer directly, compared with more than 27% when drivers swerved and hit another vehicle or an object such as a tree, pole or guardrail.
That gap is why the advice is counterintuitive: hitting the deer is usually less dangerous than avoiding it. An adult buck can weigh 150 pounds or more, so expect real front-end damage, but a guardrail or oncoming car is worse.
Does Car Insurance Cover Hitting a Deer in New Jersey?
Only if you carry comprehensive coverage. Comprehensive is optional in New Jersey, but it is the coverage that pays for damage from striking a deer, since the event is treated as an unavoidable accident rather than a fault-based crash.
If you swerve and hit another vehicle or object instead of the deer, that damage is typically handled under collision coverage. Your injuries fall under New Jersey’s no-fault system through personal injury protection (PIP).
- Hit the deer directly: comprehensive coverage, subject to your deductible.
- Swerved and hit a tree, pole or car: collision coverage.
- Injuries to you or passengers: PIP under your policy.
Check your policy declarations for comprehensive before November. If you only carry liability, a deer strike comes out of your pocket.
Do You Have to Report a Deer Collision in New Jersey?
The NJDEP says to report any deer-vehicle collision to local law enforcement immediately. New Jersey law on striking animals (N.J.S.A. 4:22-25.1) also directs motorists to report collisions with animals to police.
Reporting matters for another reason. Under state rules on dead deer, a person can only take possession of a deer killed in a collision if the crash was reported to State or municipal police as soon as possible, and the permit is valid for 90 days.
Separately, state crash-reporting rules apply to any crash involving injury or more than $500 in property damage. Call police if the deer is blocking the road, someone is hurt, or you need documentation for your insurer.
How to Lower Your Odds of Hitting a Deer in New Jersey
You cannot remove the risk, but a few habits cut it noticeably. The NJDEP and AAA give consistent guidance, summarized here:
- Slow down at dawn and dusk, especially from October through December.
- Use high beams when no one is ahead of you, since deer eyes reflect the light.
- Watch the shoulders and treat one deer as a sign that more are nearby.
- Do not tailgate. The driver ahead may have to stop suddenly.
- If a collision looks unavoidable, brake firmly and stay in your lane rather than swerving.
- Wear your seatbelt and keep your phone down, in line with the state’s hands-free law.
Pro Tip: If a deer is standing in the road and will not move, do not drive around it. Wait for it to clear.
Residents who feed wildlife can unintentionally pull deer toward roads. For the rules on that, read our guide on whether it is illegal to feed deer in New Jersey.
Your Odds of Hitting a Deer in New Jersey: Frequently Asked Questions
What Are My Odds of Hitting a Deer in New Jersey?
State Farm’s 2025-2026 analysis puts the chance of an animal collision claim at 1 in 245, ranking New Jersey 39th of 51. Other insurer datasets have produced figures in the 1 in 213 to 1 in 226 range.
What Is the Most Dangerous Month for Deer Crashes in New Jersey?
November. It accounted for 20% of all deer crashes from 2020 to 2025, according to AAA Northeast.
What Time of Day Are Deer Crashes Most Common?
Around sunrise and sunset, with the evening rush the worst. Reporting that cites the state says about 77% of crashes happen during the evening commute.
Which New Jersey County Has the Most Deer Crashes?
Monmouth County, with 1,300 deer crashes in 2025 per AAA Northeast.
Should I Swerve to Avoid a Deer?
No. AAA found injuries in more than 27% of crashes where drivers swerved and hit something else, versus 4.5% for direct deer strikes. The NJDEP also advises against swerving.
Does Insurance Cover a Deer Collision?
Comprehensive coverage pays for damage from hitting a deer directly. Without it, you cover the repair yourself.
Do I Have to Call the Police After Hitting a Deer?
The NJDEP says to report every deer-vehicle collision to local law enforcement immediately, and doing so is also required if you want to keep a deer killed in a crash.